Joe said:

Nev827 said:

I agree with most of that list, except I would have included A Rose For Ever After and A Chill Goes Through Her Veins somewhere.  Two of my perpetual favorites. 

 

Interesting.  I HATED A Rose For Ever After.  I have seen every episode countless times but when I start the season I always skip that one (Under The Gun too).  Funny thing is, I couldnt give a valid reason why I hate it.  Just makes me uncomfortable to watch it…..couldnt tell you why though

I just liked it because it gave us a window into Castle's past, I've always been a fan of Alyssa Milano, and the subtext in that episode is ridiculous in favor of Castle and Beckett getting together eventually.

I can't really argue with the list. Might make a few adjustments is all but pretty much well done imo.

Thanks for the list.

castleobserver said:

A nice list. All great episodes, but I love all Castle episodes and would have a difficult time picking my top 10.

Ha ha. I would have trouble picking a top 50!

Nev827 said:

Joe said:

Nev827 said:

I agree with most of that list, except I would have included A Rose For Ever After and A Chill Goes Through Her Veins somewhere.  Two of my perpetual favorites. 

 

Interesting.  I HATED A Rose For Ever After.  I have seen every episode countless times but when I start the season I always skip that one (Under The Gun too).  Funny thing is, I couldnt give a valid reason why I hate it.  Just makes me uncomfortable to watch it…..couldnt tell you why though

I just liked it because it gave us a window into Castle's past, I've always been a fan of Alyssa Milano, and the subtext in that episode is ridiculous in favor of Castle and Beckett getting together eventually.

Agreed. It was a very shipper episode, and very positive for C&B eventually. I love Alyssa Milano's "He's all yours" at the end of the episode.

Phoebe said:

I miss "1x05 a chill runs through her veins" I love the scene when Beckett comes to Castles loft and the the scene in the flat of the victim and another fav of me "3x11 Nikki Heat" that episode was so classy.

For my share the 2 parter of season 2 was better than in season 3 but tastes differ [Image Can Not Be Found]

The more I think about it the harder it gets for me to make a choice between the two 2-parters. So… I just stopped trying to compare them. I slightly preferred the case in the season 3 two-parter. And the scenes between C&B. It was a much more dramatic two-parter than the one of season 2. And I always preferred the more dramatic episodes of the show. That being said, I also loved the scenes between C&B in the season 2 two-parter, and also the fact that there was no SO back then, and the cliffhanger at the end of Tick Tick Tick was great. So…. yeah, hard to make a choice.