The first, best, most accurate and only Castle fan site that allows you to interact with the Castle cast & crew

It’s Only Words (Another article by Trueheart)

“For a man who earns his living with words,” Rick Castle’s mother Martha counsels him, “you sure have a hell of a time finding them when it counts.” And so it is: the paradox of the wordsmith, who cannot find the words to profess his love to his beloved. Oh, how he tries and it is painful to watch. Rick sits across from Kate in the bio hazard tent in “Set Up,” mid season three, listening to Kate tell him about the kind of man she wants, a man to be there for her and someone with whom she can dive into life. Can’t she see Rick and can’t he speak and tell her to open her eyes and see him there. I am here for you always. Can’t he find, then, the words he later says as Kate lay bleeding in his arms and near death: “Stay with me; don’t leave me; I love you Kate.”

The beauty of their unspoken love or perhaps the difficulty of their love is they do talk but not with their voices; they speak with their eyes. Castle creator Andrew Marlowe once explained: “But sometimes they do it with their eyes because, they already know, already know, the words.” Perhaps their eyes do inscribe their love, but sometimes it isn’t enough, especially if one of them is not ready and the other is on a different page.

At first glance, the man who talks all the time, tells stories and enjoys “smart ass not jackass” repartee, theories and witticisms, doesn’t have the words “I love you” until it is almost too late, but I contend that everything he does declares his love for Kate, and I see numerous words or phrases which resound throughout Castle, Rick’s words, words of love, encouragement and praise, in fact, inspiration. Indeed, Rick’s words encompass a personal philosophy and a reflection on life’s emotions and endeavors; they are words to build on, and in fact, the words of encouragement and faith which make me admire Rick Castle, a character from a television show. They are words to live by for anyone…words I now embrace.

Before Rick pledges “always” to Kate or calls himself her “partner,” he calls her “extraordinary,” and she is. Rick defines Kate and her extraordinary qualities. She does not give up on the quest to find the guilty or give up honoring the victims. Trying to help and encourage her when she feels like she has let herself or someone else down, Rick reminds Kate: “Most people come up against a wall, they give up; not you; you don’t let go; you don’t back down.”

Ironically, a few years later we see those walls surface, personal ones, walls she must overcome to allow herself to find survivor’s forgiveness, to seek love again and to find solace after her mother’s murder. Once again she must scale or break down those walls to have the relationship she truly wants with Rick. Bravely, Kate is working with her therapist to overcome her fears and the walls she has erected. As for extraordinary, who can deny the beauty of Rick’s dedication in his first Nikki Heat novel “Heat Wave,” truly a love letter to Kate: To the extraordinary K.B. and all my friends at the 12th

All of us must work on and tackle the walls that disappoint or hurt us, the barriers, walls that prevent us from achieving great things, from facing adversity and from living our lives completely. In the tent scene Rick speaks to Kate regarding her relationship with Josh. If you live your life with “one foot out of the door,” for fear of committing yourself, “it’s hard to know where you stand.” Even more profoundly, Rick once told Kate, “If we don’t believe in magic there is no chance of finding it.” And isn’t this true of every worthwhile endeavor? Living life fully requires risking failure. Taking it one step further, as psychologist Dr. Wayne Dyer wrote, “You’ll see it when you believe it.”

Rick tries to help his daughter recognize her own extraordinary qualities when Alexis’ application to Stanford is rejected and Alexis believes her life to be a lie; all of her efforts are as nothing. She cannot see beyond her failure. “Rejection is not failure; the failure is in giving up,” Rick advises. It is how we handle rejection which sets our course. He does not give up on his daughter, Kate, his mother or himself. Rejection undoubtedly dogs a writer, in Rick’s case twenty times, but Rick is determined, and he tries to impart this message to his daughter.

In season one’s episode five, “A Chill Goes through Her Veins,” I recognized in Rick the most positive and hopeful, hero I have ever encountered. Rick’s sunny outlook radiates throughout the story, in fact throughout four years of Castle, revealing a man who believes in possibilities and second chances, simply in hope. This conversation reveals his outlook but also sheds light on Kate’s lack of hope. On this occasion he and Kate are calling it a night and departing when Rick says, “until tomorrow.”

“You can’t just say goodnight,” Kate returns.

“I am a writer, until tomorrow is more hopeful.”

“I am a cop. Good night.”

Something always pulls me back to this conversation, no matter what I write, for it shines so much light on Rick’s personality and philosophy. Indeed, over the four years of their relationship, Rick, with his love, helps Kate restore her own hope and belief in the promise of tomorrow.

For Rick hope is alive; it springs eternal. A seemingly, shallow playboy-writer presents the most important words of the entire episode, indeed, the entire four seasons. Hope exists if we look for it and believe in it. Hope guides Rick and keeps him steady; hope helps him endure embarrassment, or failure; hope keeps love close even in dark times; hope binds him faithfully to loved ones. Hope remains true and gives us all another chance… and so, “until tomorrow is more hopeful.”

I hold on to and live by this message of hope, and I never forget the man, who said these words or the writer who gave him these words, for they bolster my faith in difficult times and give me hope in my own battles… with cancer.

In an insightful moment a while back, I realized that life often imitates art, especially as I recalled Kate’s former boyfriend Will speaking to Kate about Rick: “You never told him how you stood in line for an hour just to get your book signed. How his novels got you through your mother’s death.” I could relate to Kate and understand because I felt the same way. For me, delighting in the Castle characters, in their love story, gets me through adversity. Most particularly, Rick’s expressions of hope in all possibilities gave me solace while witnessing my son in law’s brave fight with cancer and the battle he lost January 2, 2011, leaving my daughter, and my four year old granddaughter behind.

Rick and his until tomorrow outlook on life became a talisman for me. But in one of life’s ironies, a few short months later, in October 2011, I needed my talisman, my hope more than ever. I prepped for a routine colonoscopy on a Monday in October. Of course, I could not let anything interfere with viewing Castle so I dashed back and forth from the bathroom, trying not to miss a second of my favorite show.

It turns out it was my least favorite episode, anyway, for I could have strangled everyone, especially that poser, femme –fatale Serena Kaye threatening our Kate; the nerve. How appropriate the title of this episode, “Eye of the Beholder,” and this beholder gave the trespasser the stink eye. At least Serena gets it right when she tells Kate: “I don’t steal things that belong to someone else.” But Rick makes an ass out of himself as did everyone, and I guess grumpy me could not see the humor in anything while running to vomit every minute.

It’s the only episode I don’t care to write about or DVR. Well, on second thought, I did laugh when Kate slams the door to the interrogation room in Rick’s face, claiming that he is compromised after the kiss, and Rick making the strangling Kate motions behind said doors and Kate’s back, or his attempt to save face with the guys. How about kissing the information out of Serena…too funny? While I’m at it, I did like Kate’s session with her therapist. By the way, Kate, he is waiting for you? Woman up! But over all…”Meh!” Who am I kidding? I didn’t have writer’s block; it must be some other blockage.

Obviously, something was wrong with me, and into the hospital emergency room I went. I had an obstruction, a large tumor removed on Wednesday, ultimately staying in the hospital for two more weeks, and rehabbing for another week, to boot. But I saw my Castle each Monday, even if I had to mow down the nurse and aids to get them out of the room and my line of vision so I could see the poor- quality picture, with the volume just right, with no silly distractions such as blood work or medicine or anything else while Castle was on. Oh, I guess I made a few friends talking, not writing about my favorite show and sharing with them anything I thought up, making a few converts along the way (if only to humor me and shut me up). Oh, but I am sure you have been there, too…with… the disbelievers.

After sending pathology slides around to every great cancer institute, all saying I was the one to stump the best minds, the pathologists figured it out, and by the end of January they had a course of action to treat my very rare and serious cancer. I am being treated with chemo, now through a first round of six weeks, and beginning a second round in fact, and it is working.

But the cancer did spread and it took labs in Vancouver to determine the nature of this cancer. Of course, Nathan and Stana are Canadian, too. Yes, I know, I have too much time on my hands, but I do love to write, never having had much time to do so as a high school teacher. And so I write and adhere to Rick’s screen saver which I have adopted as my own: “You should be writing.”

Indeed, so much has been written about Rick and Kate and especially the words “always and partners.” Rick and Kate declare their unspoken pledge and devotion to each other with these code words of promise and love. With his “always” promise, Rick protects and guards Kate. He comforts her while trapped in ice, protects her in battle and supports her in her PTSD crisis.

He professes this word to allay her fears and to show that they love unconditionally, especially in “Kill Shot” when she thanks him for not pushing her and giving her space to work out her problems. The one time she says always to him in season three seems incongruous at first. But Kate is responding to Rick’s heartfelt thank you to her.

Remembering the passionate Bon Jovi love song, “Thank You for Loving Me,” I realize this is what Rick and Kate mean this time when Kate responds “always”: “Thank you, for loving me. For being my eyes when I couldn’t see. For parting my lips when I couldn’t breathe. Thank you for loving me. When I couldn’t fly, oh, you gave me wings. You parted my lips when I couldn’t breathe. Thank you for loving me. Thank you for loving me.”

Being enfolded in this promise of unconditional love for always is such a remarkable message. We fans live for this code word, “always;” I love you no matter what changes. Rick switches to the word “partners,” but this, too, is a word that strengthens their relationship and hints at so much more, partners in so many different ways. When Rick returns to saying “always,” so special in “Kill Shot,” Kate emerges reassured, heartened, ready to open up to her therapist, to confide in him that she wants to be so much more, for herself and for Rick, who is waiting for his partner.

The evolution of the word “enough” is another great word story. Who can forget Kate’s ripping into Rick in “Knockout” telling him she was tired of hanging around with the school’s funniest kid and it wasn’t enough? That had to hurt to the quick, for Rick had done everything a man could do.

But in “Rise” “enough” has changed to become another beloved word in the Rick and Kate lexicon. “It isn’t enough, but it is enough for now.” Kate says this to Rick at the end of “Rise,” and Rick assures his daughter with the same words in his answer to Alexis’ concerned questions: “Does she make you happy,” and “Is it enough”:

“It is enough for now,” Rick humbly reveals to his daughter. I, too, hold on to these words as do Rick and Kate, and I am glad I learned them.

Finally these ultimate Rick Castle words highlight and compliment all of the other passionate and profound words: “Give it time,” and “You will figure it out.” He uses these words to advise Alexis in her moment of rejection, words which mean the following: Don’t try to solve everything at once. Let life unfold a bit, one step at a time. Try your hardest, but fight; don’t expect immediate, one breath solutions. The journey is worth the struggle.

“Give it time.” Rick earnestly utters these words to Kate, in “Rise,” in the scene between them, at her desk after the usual, loving, coffee- offering ritual. Addressing her post traumatic stress, Rick tries with all of his love on display to convince Kate she is not fine and to step away from her mother’s murder investigation.

Just look at his face and his soul-searching eyes; listen to his compassionate voice and know that everything Rick embodies is on display: his love; his hope; his compassion; his fear. Will she listen to him or kick him out as she did when last he tried to tell her she was not fine? Rick earnestly beseeches her: “I’m just saying give it time… I promise you we’ll figure this out. We’re going to find them and we’re going to make them pay; just not today.” This exchange is the heart and soul of “Rise” and the heart and soul, the essence of everything Rick Castle.

“Give it time; we will figure it out, just not today.” Is there any wonder as to the power of Rick’s words when he says to Kate, “Don’t let them rob you of your life.”? Indeed these words speak volumes to me, not yet a cancer survivor but on my way. Kate tells Rick: “If I don’t do this,” (search for my mother’s killer), “I don’t know who I am.” We all search for our identity and our purpose in life. Rick’s answer to Kate is so hopeful, positive and life affirming, indeed, soul proclaiming: “You are who you always were.”

Yes, words have great power to heal, to uplift and to save. We have Rick’s “only words,” from across four seasons, so hard to count them even after examining them, and so encompassing. Amazingly, they are spoken by the man who uses words for a living, but who has a hard time vocalizing specific words of love for his partner Kate.

Still sometimes, it is the words unspoken that pile up inside, that stifle the breath and jam the heart; words that need to be said. Secrets which need to be aired are buried alive and become destructive; as Rick says: “Secrets are like time bombs; eventually they explode.” And so they may as we approach the end of the fourth season.

The fourth season is about rising from the ashes of broken dreams and heartbreak, from death and its horror, and our two lovers make significant strides, with loving smiles, and tender touches, pure joy in each other’s presence; but there are unspoken words and deeds, secrets ready to explode. From the swing set and its chains that bind them, they speak, with words and no words; he will wait for her; she needs him to come back to her. He returns; he cannot help himself; Kate’s swagger returns; she is recovering.

But, when asked by her therapist about her jealousy towards Serena or what Rick means to her, Kate cannot say these true words: I am jealous because he is mine, my love. One tells his mother the relationship is complicated and is mirrored by the other in therapy. Still they wait for each other. They speak to each other about their relationship more honestly than ever before; they are a couple, though never mutually declared.

They work together, and smile together, musing over other lovers with such sub-text, for which Rick is a self-proclaimed master. They cannot deny their need for each other. Rick questions Lanie and Esposito’s relationship: Can’t they see that they need each other; why do they do this to themselves, and we sigh with exasperation. Rick and Kate have reconciled, but those words unspoken may well break their hearts and ours with their star-crossed pain. Some words need to be said.

I return to a discussion Rick and Kate had a few seasons ago. Kate, with such sub text, reveals heartbreak to Rick when she questions love and its risks. He will only disappoint you in the end so why risk it. Rick’s reply still resonates with me: “Because the heart wants what the heart wants.” Both Rick and Kate need to risk all. Kate must tell Rick I love you, but I am so afraid of losing you. And Rick must risk all and say, I love you, and I am so afraid of losing you. Words need to be said.

Thinking about words and their ramifications, I unexpectedly, in one of those aha moments, virtually stumbled upon the perfect expression of the power of words. Reading an article on line, I became attuned again to a lovely song by the Bee Gees, appropriately titled “Words.” I have loved this song forever, but now “Words” and its creators have a renewed significance for me.

Robin Gibb is a cancer survivor. His eighteen month battle with colon and liver cancer has been a success, for he is now in remission. Overjoyed for Robin, I gravitated to this hopeful story. This true drama’s outcome gives me inspiration and reminds me of the hope I have and the hope I feel when watching and writing about Castle. And, of course: “Words.” It all makes sense, this love song.

The following Bee Gee lyrics, so hopeful, seem so in tune with my favorite want to be lovers Kate and Rick: “This world has lost its glory. Let’s start a brand new story now, my love. Right now there’ll be no other time, and I can show you how, my love. Talk in everlasting words and dedicate them all to me. And I will give you all my life; I’m here if you should call to me. You think that I don’t even mean a single word I say. It’s only words, and words are all I have, to take your heart away. It’s only words…and words are all I have…to take…your…heart…away. It’s only words….”

———

This is a member contributed article. Would you like to submit an article or episode review? Use our submission form to contribute.

About Trueheart

Peggy is a retired high school teacher and since the 2009 beginning, a proud devotee of all things Castle. I guess you might call this old teach a shipper, and doesn't that beat all.

Comments

  1. Okay, so I’m a “Caskett” shipper, big-time. Everyone knows it – my family, friends, coworkers, even the folks at Starbucks. I tell everyone about “the best show ever.” I do it, not just so they can enjoy the show, but for a purely selfish reason. I want Castle to go on forever. The more people that watch, the better the chances of that happening.
    Too often, I feel my words fall short. Then I read Trueheart’s words and I wish she could speak to all of those people for me. Trueheart, like Rick, is a wordsmith. Being abe to verbalize a deep understanding of life, and of course all things Castle, is a gift. Fortunately she share’s that gift with us.
    To Trueheart – Castle has helped me through some difficulties this past year, too, though nothing nearly as serious as what you’re going through. It’s odd what a tv show can become under the guise of a crime procedural-mystery-drama-romantic comedy-suspense thriller. I wonder sometimes if Andrew Marlowe knows what he has created. You should be writing. I hope you continue to share your gift with us. They’re not just words. I wish for you a full and speedy recovery.

  2. You have a gift with writing. I couldn’t have said ‘caskett’ better myself. Now let’s sit back and wait for castle and beckett to make words and finally declare their love<3

  3. That article was truly inspirational, you have a gift with words. I’ve been through some tough times in my life, and I know what it feels like to need to hold on to something to make it through. It is amazing that you found in Castle the hope and strength to fight for your life, I admire you. I wish you the best :)

  4. Great writing! I actually read it all and with my level of concentration thats a big compliment to you!

  5. Peggy,

    I absolutely love reading your essays about Castle! I truly look forward to your insights, and I wish I could be as eloquent as you in my own writing.

    P.S. I am sorry to hear about your cancer. Keep fighting. Be strong… always.

  6. What an amazing and truly beautiful piece Trueheart. I enjoy reading anything you write but this piece touched my heart.
    As always you captured the essence of Kate and Rick and all they mean to each other. Your eloquence on Caskett is second to none and I too wish the world at large could read your words and come to understand just why Castle means so much to so many.
    Wishing you joy, happiness and a complete recovery so you cmay continue to delight and entertain us with your insightful reviews for the many Castle season to come.

  7. A wordsmith you truly are and a shipper. Keep up the great writing. I know that writing brings you such joy, and it can go on forever.

    May your recovery be just as promising.

  8. wish4always says:

    Peggy, your title is a misnomer. The above article is anything but words.
    It’s hopes, dreams, joy, sorrow, soul connections all in one. It really is True of Heart.
    Thank you for putting this amazing piece of art together so that we can share in your thoughts and I wish you a truly speedy recovery.
    Much strength to you in this difficult time.

  9. Trueheart says:

    Dear fellow Castle fans,

    Thank you! Your best wishes and kind words inspire and support me, and I am extremely grateful. Anita mentioned earlier that she wonders if Andrew Marlowe is aware of what he has created and how profound an impact Castle has.

    Judging by the integrity and constancy of the fan base, he does. Indeed, Castle fans have an especially generous spirit and a kindness, an understanding of the heart, and its journey to love and understanding.

    Truly this awareness begins with Mr. Marlowe and his writing staff and flows through his wonderful actors and crew. We are moved by their dedication to detail, the development of character, and their infinite understanding of the wonderful love story so carefully rendered.

    They and our Castle community are extraordinary.

  10. Dear Peggy:  I really appreciate you sharing your personal walk through the fire, and how important it is to focus on the life’s enjoyments that enable us to rise above such things.  This, plus your Castle passion, has helped me to view you as friend, even though all I truly know about you are your words.  I suspect you are a lady around my age, too, which validates my thinking that no matter what happens to us physically, romance is eternal, as is a youthful spirit if we permit it to be so.  I was pleasantly surprised to see you are Canadian too!  Like you, I am apprehensive about where this Caskett thing is going after last night’s show – I don’t want disappointments either after following all of this time.  Take good care of yourself, and please do keep writing – because ‘words are all (we) have, to take (our hearts) away.’ 

  11. Ilvcastle says:

    Trueheart, What a beautiful and moving depiction of all things Castle. I too use Castle as a means of escape. My husband is in a stage of Alzhiemer and I hide in Castle to get to a place of hope and promise. Thank you so much for your courage and strength. I am a very senior person but I still love love. I hope our writters help Rick and Kate find theirs.
    I will keep you in my prayers.

    • Trueheart says:

      Dear Ilvcastle,
      You are an inspiration to all. I wish you solace in that place of promise and hope that Castle brings you every week, and may you always keep hope and love alive in your heart.

      In I Cor. 13:13, I find one of the most powerful expressions of what is truly important in life:

      “And now these three remain: faith, hope and love. But the greatest of these is love.”

      Thank you for your prayers; I shall keep you in mine, too.

  12. Did anyone notice that when Castle’s attitude with regards to his relationship with Beckett changed, so did a particular choice of words?

    In Season 1, Castle stated:

    “I’m a writer. ‘Goodnight’ is boring. ‘Until tomorrow’ is more… hopeful.”

    At the end of “47 Seconds”, Castle has lost all hope and simply said:

    “Goodnight.”

    If I’m not mistaken, I believe this is the first time he’s said that to Beckett.

    As Steve Kloves (screenwriter of the Harry Potter films) wrote: “Words are our most inexhaustible source of magic. They are capable of both inflicting injury and remedying it.” It’s ironic that the man who makes his living with words can’t find the words of love when he needs them, but he can so quickly find the words that can hurt!

    • Trueheart says:

      Great catch! I remember a poignant scene in One Life to Lose, 3×18, aired just about a year ago. Rick gifts Kate with a memorable present of a picture of the Temptation Lane cast, a picture which reminds Kate of time with her mother when they watched the show together and it made Kate feel safe and at home.

      This was a beautiful scene of the two of them , another subtle one by the writers, with Rick and Kate so happy until Josh calls Kate on the cell and interrupts their magical moment. Rick leaves Kate, quite saddened, walks away from her desk, much the same way he walks away from her hospital be in Rise, and as he parts he says to her, in mumbled words, and so down…”I’ll see you.” I remember feeling so heartbroken for him. I don’t think he was inflicting injury upon her then or now. He is simply down.

      • I agree… I really believe that he’s not trying to hurt Beckett on purpose — I truly believe that he’s just trying to tell her how hurt he is without using so many words (ironically enough).

  13. You have articulated my worst fears re. this show. I did catch that, but still hope that it was a knee-jerk reaction from being hurt.

    • Trueheart says:

      I agree with your idea that it is a knee jerk reaction,(I hope) but I also feel that he is acting so out of character right now. These writers have us tracking their every word. Does any other show ask this of us? I am still amazed.

  14. Lostcause says:

    I have to say after 47 Seconds, this hole almost but not quite thing has happened once too many times for me.

    I do not want to see the Castle version of Bones, or whatever other show that keeps making them mere seconds and flukes from saying what they want.

    This isn’t high school, they deal in life and death daily, yet they haven’t been able to take 5 minutes after work, to get said what they want to say?

    Come on writers! For the first time I have to say the Castle/Beckett thing is going downhill for me. If this is them buying another season of unspoken words and feelings – I can easily see myself getting more annoyed than I am currently. Get it done of move on.

  15. kittycat says:

    Lostcause said
    I have to say after 47 Seconds, this hole almost but not quite thing has happened once too many times for me.

    I do not want to see the Castle version of Bones, or whatever other show that keeps making them mere seconds and flukes from saying what they want.

    This isn’t high school, they deal in life and death daily, yet they haven’t been able to take 5 minutes after work, to get said what they want to say?

    Come on writers! For the first time I have to say the Castle/Beckett thing is going downhill for me. If this is them buying another season of unspoken words and feelings – I can easily see myself getting more annoyed than I am currently. Get it done of move on.

    It is going to be rough for the next few episodes, but I am very hopeful that good things are coming by the end of the season (Stana said it herself). I think Castle and Beckett are coming to a point where they can’t hide from each other or their feelings anymore. The secrets are going to come out and with that, the truth. It is going to be one emotional roller coaster and I have my seat belt fastened for a hell of a ride grin

  16. Hello.  Anyone else but me wonder about possible character development for Beckett’s father?  Also, NF has said that AWM’s handling of the Season 4 finale was ‘deft.’  Stana has said ‘shippers would be pleased.  The title of the episode is “Always.”  Any thoughts about how this epi won’t be the Castle version of the Bones hook-up?

  17. Toronto says:

    Thank you, this is so insightful and beautiful, and the care with which you have followed words like “enough” is manna to a philosopher (me, sometimes). I never noticed that little theme which you have pinned. It seems to me, however, that to focus so much on words focusses our attention on Castle (which you do in your piece). Beckett deserves equal consideration for being the sometime bearer of what could be called the gestural language of physicality. I think that one of the things that makes the series so complicated is that Castle and Beckett wander back and forth across the stereotypical male/female categories, which are often cast linguistically. Castle is more “feminine” than Beckett — she is the cop with the power, he is the assistant sitting in the side seat by the desk. She can tell him to get lost. She is the first through the door, etc. She can give orders that will be obeyed.

    Beckett is the pragmatist, the driver. Castle is the dreamer, the passenger. This again puts him in this very awkward position, where essentially he is waiting on her to make the move, which is not your usual male role. A writer is a witness, not “the real thing”; female, not male (to be absolutely clear, I am discussing historic cultural archetypes here!!!!!!). Castle’s role is to throw words and ideas at a case, but in the end it is Beckett who is in charge of violence, the law, and power. It is interesting that when we look at the origins of Romance (and we are dealing with a romance here), it is this inversion of roles that got it going: the essence of the Provencal romance is that a male is put into a worshipful role towards a more powerful female, and can only woo her with song and story until she deigns to listen and finally agree. This is the role of the creative writer in romances: otherwise he is a dorky nerd (e.g. Castle with his writers vest).

    Interestingly, he can say “I love you” to her, and nothing happens. This is a classic writer’s moment. The words ought to have power, but they have seemingly no immediate effect on the “real world” (though in the end, their words will shape the world).

    So for him, words are everything. But words and writing aren’t everything.

    Gesture is language too; feeling is something; action has meaning; being there is a form of love. I think that one of the issues of the show is the struggle between worlds of made up language and worlds of let’s call it “real ife”, which include language, sure, but also things beyond language. The symbol of that is the fact that the show began with Castle seeking inspiration for his next book, and in the end “it isn’t about the books anymore”. And just when he realized that, circumstances rendered him also speechless and powerless. It is interesting how much being driven into that corner has messed him up this season, and flummoxed the writers for whom Castle is their surrogate. It shows how much the show is captive to writers (but what else would one expect?) . But (dare I say it?), for him to be without words for awhile is good for him.

    And here I agree with “Lostcause” — my objection to the show at the moment is that it is too captive to the writerly: the writers are treating the characters as if they were algebraic characters to solve – or delay solving — while denying them ordinariness. So a certain formulaic quality is deadening things, and making the characters and the forthcoming situations predictable.

  18. skyisblue1 says:

    Simply beautiful. Thank you.